What is a retire earlier or later comparison?
A retire earlier or later comparison shows how moving the retirement age changes the savings needed to fund the same retirement spending. This calculator works out the extra amount to save each month to retire at the earlier age, compared with the later one, under the growth and inflation assumptions you enter.
Beyond the numbers
The maths shows one side. These are the things only you can weigh.
- Time and healthThe years just after retiring are often the most active. For many people that time is worth more than a larger cushion later.
- Work that gives meaningSome people enjoy their work and the people around them. Working a few more years can be a choice, not a burden.
- A softer landingPart-time work, consulting or a gradual step back can bridge the gap between the two ages.
- Family and health costsChildren's education, ageing parents and medical costs can change the picture. Leave room for them.
- Living with uncertaintyMarkets, inflation and lifespans are hard to predict. A margin of safety turns a plan that just works into one that holds up.
How it's calculated
This uses exactly the same method as the retirement calculator, once for each age. The saving needed is found by search: the smallest whole monthly amount for which the money never runs short before the planning age.
Assumptions
- Constant returns before and during retirement, and constant inflation.
- Saving at the start of each month until retirement; spending rises with inflation from today.
- No pension, rental or other income in retirement; fees and taxes are not included.
Worked example
Aged 35 with 10 lakh rupees saved and saving 20,000 rupees a month at 10% before retirement, 7% after and 6% inflation, wanting 50,000 rupees a month in today's money: retiring at 55 needs about 54,199 rupees a month to last to 85, and retiring at 60 about 32,815 rupees, so retiring five years earlier needs about 21,384 rupees a month more.
Retire earlier or later at different savings levels
Aged 35 with ₹10,00,000 saved, assumed growth of 10% before and 7% after retiring, 6% inflation and ₹50,000 a month in today's money to age 85. Saving needed to last: ₹54,199 a month at 55, ₹32,815 at 60.
| Monthly saving | Money lasts, retiring at 55 | Money lasts, retiring at 60 | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| ₹10,000 | To about 63 | To about 70 | Neither lasts to 85 |
| ₹20,000 | To about 67 | To about 76 | Neither lasts to 85 |
| ₹33,000 | To about 73 | Through 85 | Only retiring at 60 lasts |
| ₹55,000 | Through 85 | Through 85 | Both last to 85 |
Common scenarios
Illustrative worked scenarios in rupees. Rates and growth are assumptions; actual outcomes can differ.
Starting at age 35 with ₹2,50,000 and ₹5,000 monthly saving, retiring at 55 versus 60 is modelled with assumed 8% growth before retirement, 7% afterward and 6% inflation, spending ₹12,500 monthly in today’s money through age 85. Balances at the respective retirement ages: Earlier retirement is ₹41,96,437, lower than later retirement at ₹66,21,877 under these assumptions. Try these inputs
Starting at age 35 with ₹10,00,000 and ₹20,000 monthly saving, retiring at 55 versus 60 is modelled with assumed 10% growth before retirement, 7% afterward and 6% inflation, spending ₹50,000 monthly in today’s money through age 85. Balances at the respective retirement ages: Earlier retirement is ₹2,26,42,012, lower than later retirement at ₹3,88,14,752 under these assumptions. Try these inputs
Starting at age 35 with ₹20,00,000 and ₹40,000 monthly saving, retiring at 55 versus 60 is modelled with assumed 11% growth before retirement, 7% afterward and 6% inflation, spending ₹1,00,000 monthly in today’s money through age 85. Balances at the respective retirement ages: Earlier retirement is ₹5,28,12,953, lower than later retirement at ₹9,45,19,025 under these assumptions. Try these inputs
Starting at age 35 with ₹50,00,000 and ₹1,00,000 monthly saving, retiring at 55 versus 60 is modelled with assumed 12% growth before retirement, 7% afterward and 6% inflation, spending ₹2,50,000 monthly in today’s money through age 85. Balances at the respective retirement ages: Earlier retirement is ₹15,43,77,560, lower than later retirement at ₹28,87,05,841 under these assumptions. Try these inputs
Questions
Why does a few years make such a big difference?
Retiring earlier removes years of saving and growth, and adds years of spending at higher, inflated prices. Both work against you at once.
What if the money runs short?
The comparison shows when. Options include saving more, retiring a little later, spending less in retirement or adding other income.
Does it include a pension?
No. If you expect a pension or other income, lower the monthly spending to the part your savings must cover.
Which returns should I use?
Use cautious, long-term assumptions, usually lower after retirement when money is often kept safer.
Sources
Add it to your site
Show this calculator on your own website or blog, free. It keeps working as we update it.
HaatBeat