What is a lease or buy car comparison?
A lease or buy car comparison weighs paying to use a car for a fixed term against buying it outright or with a loan. This calculator works out the total lease payments, the car's value at the end of the term and the savings each option leaves, so the two paths can be compared.
Beyond the numbers
The maths shows one side. These are the things only you can weigh.
- Always a newer carLeasing makes it easy to drive a recent model with the latest safety features and few repairs.
- Freedom of ownershipAn owned car can be driven any distance, modified and sold when you choose. A lease has rules.
- Predictable costsLeases with servicing included make monthly costs steady, which some households value.
- Ending early is costlyLeaving a lease early can mean large charges. Make sure the term fits your plans.
- A car is not an investmentEither way the car loses value. The question is how much, and who carries that loss.
How it's calculated
Both households spend the same each month, so only the choice differs. At the end of the lease the leased car goes back; the bought car is worth its price less the yearly fall in value.
Assumptions
- The car is bought outright; with a loan, see the car cash or loan page.
- Insurance, servicing and taxes cost the same either way, unless the lease includes them (then subtract them from the lease payment).
- The car's value falls by a steady yearly rate; real resale prices vary.
- Money not spent is saved at a steady return.
Worked example
A 35,000 dollar car losing 15% a year, against a 36-month lease at 450 dollars a month with 3,000 dollars upfront and 500 dollars of return fees, with savings at 5%: buying ends about 2,266 dollars ahead, with a car worth about 21,494 dollars. In India, a 10 lakh rupee car against an 18,000 rupee monthly subscription over 36 months, with savings at 8%, leaves buying about 83,528 rupees ahead.
Lease or buy as the car loses value faster
A ₹10,00,000 car against a 36-month lease at ₹18,000 a month with ₹10,000 of return fees, savings at an assumed 8% a year. The buyer keeps the car; the leaser keeps the price invested. The result depends on these assumptions.
| Assumed yearly fall in value | Car worth at the end | Buyer ends with | Leaser ends with | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 10% | ₹7,29,000 | ₹14,58,640 | ₹12,60,237 | Buying ahead by ₹1,98,403 |
| 15% | ₹6,14,125 | ₹13,43,765 | ₹12,60,237 | Buying ahead by ₹83,528 |
| 20% | ₹5,12,000 | ₹12,41,640 | ₹12,60,237 | Leasing ahead by ₹18,597 |
| 25% | ₹4,21,875 | ₹11,51,515 | ₹12,60,237 | Leasing ahead by ₹1,08,722 |
| 30% | ₹3,43,000 | ₹10,72,640 | ₹12,60,237 | Leasing ahead by ₹1,87,597 |
Common scenarios
Illustrative worked scenarios in rupees. Rates and growth are assumptions; actual outcomes can differ.
Buying a ₹5,00,000 car is compared with a lease costing ₹10,000 monthly for 36 months, ₹0 upfront and ₹5,000 at the end, assuming 15% yearly depreciation and 6% yearly growth on savings. Ending net positions: Buying is ₹7,00,424, higher than leasing at ₹5,93,340 under these assumptions. Try these inputs
Buying a ₹10,00,000 car is compared with a lease costing ₹18,000 monthly for 36 months, ₹0 upfront and ₹10,000 at the end, assuming 15% yearly depreciation and 8% yearly growth on savings. Ending net positions: Buying is ₹13,43,765, higher than leasing at ₹12,60,237 under these assumptions. Try these inputs
Buying a ₹20,00,000 car is compared with a lease costing ₹36,000 monthly for 36 months, ₹0 upfront and ₹20,000 at the end, assuming 15% yearly depreciation and 9% yearly growth on savings. Ending net positions: Buying is ₹27,09,748, higher than leasing at ₹25,97,291 under these assumptions. Try these inputs
Buying a ₹50,00,000 car is compared with a lease costing ₹90,000 monthly for 36 months, ₹0 upfront and ₹50,000 at the end, assuming 15% yearly depreciation and 10% yearly growth on savings. Ending net positions: Buying is ₹68,30,989, higher than leasing at ₹66,90,909 under these assumptions. Try these inputs
Questions
Can I use this as a car subscription vs buying calculator?
Use the subscription payment as the lease payment, subtracting what a buyer would pay separately for any included insurance or servicing, so both sides cover the same things. Include upfront and return fees in their fields. The comparison uses your inputs over the chosen lease period; it does not retrieve subscription quotes.
Why can leasing look cheaper month to month but cost more overall?
Lease payments cover the value the car loses plus the lessor's costs and profit. At the end you own nothing, while a buyer still has the car.
Is it cheaper to lease or buy a car?
Usually buying ends ahead over the lease, because a buyer still owns the car at the end. In the 35,000 dollar example buying ends about 2,266 dollars ahead. Leasing can come out level or ahead when the car loses value quickly or the lease is priced keenly.
When does leasing make sense in the numbers?
When the car loses value quickly, the lease is priced keenly, or you would otherwise replace the car every few years anyway.
What happens if I drive more than the lease allows?
Excess distance is charged when the car goes back. Include an estimate in the fees.
Sources
Add it to your site
Show this calculator on your own website or blog, free. It keeps working as we update it.
HaatBeat