What is an own car or cabs comparison?
An own car or cabs comparison weighs the cost of owning a private car against paying for cab rides for the same monthly travel. This calculator works out the car's value at the end of the period and the savings each choice leaves, using the monthly distance and cab fare per kilometre you enter.
Beyond the numbers
The maths shows one side. These are the things only you can weigh.
- Freedom and spontaneityA car is there whenever you want it: early mornings, late nights, last-minute trips. That convenience is hard to price.
- Family needsSmall children, elderly parents or someone unwell can make a car feel essential, whatever the numbers say.
- Stress of driving and parkingTraffic, parking and maintenance take time and energy. Some people are happy to hand all of that over.
- Reliability of cabsAvailability and surge pricing vary by city and time. Where cabs are hard to find, a car brings certainty.
- A middle pathMany families keep one car instead of two, or rent a car for trips. Mixing options can capture most of the savings.
How it's calculated
Both households start with the car's price. Costs rise once a year by the same rate, and savings grow at your assumed return. Comparing what each has at the end shows the full cost of owning against using cabs.
Assumptions
- The car is bought outright; with a loan, add the interest to the monthly cost of owning.
- The car's value falls by a steady yearly rate.
- Fares and running costs rise by the same rate once a year.
- Money not spent is saved at a steady return; accidents and resale costs are not included.
Worked example
An 8 lakh rupee car losing 15% a year and costing 12,000 rupees a month to run, against cabs at 18 rupees a km for 600 km a month (10,800 rupees), costs rising 5% a year and savings at 8%: after 5 years, using cabs ends about 9.34 lakh rupees ahead. At 1,500 km a month, owning the car ends about 3.72 lakh rupees ahead.
Own a car or use cabs by distance travelled
A ₹8,00,000 car losing 15% a year and costing ₹12,000 a month to run, against cabs at ₹18 a kilometre. Costs rise 5% a year, savings earn an assumed 8%, over 5 years. The result depends on these assumptions.
| Kilometres a month | Cab cost a month | Owner ends with | Cab user ends with | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 300 | ₹5,400 | ₹3,54,964 | ₹17,23,656 | Cabs ahead by ₹13,68,692 |
| 600 | ₹10,800 | ₹3,54,964 | ₹12,88,564 | Cabs ahead by ₹9,33,600 |
| 1,000 | ₹18,000 | ₹8,38,400 | ₹11,91,877 | Cabs ahead by ₹3,53,476 |
| 1,300 | ₹23,400 | ₹12,73,492 | ₹11,91,877 | Owning ahead by ₹81,616 |
| 1,500 | ₹27,000 | ₹15,63,554 | ₹11,91,877 | Owning ahead by ₹3,71,677 |
| 2,000 | ₹36,000 | ₹22,88,708 | ₹11,91,877 | Owning ahead by ₹10,96,831 |
Common scenarios
Illustrative worked scenarios in rupees. Rates and growth are assumptions; actual outcomes can differ.
A ₹2,00,000 car costing ₹4,500 monthly to run is compared with 600 cab kilometres monthly at ₹12 per kilometre over 3 years, assuming 15% yearly depreciation, 5% annual running-cost increases and 6% yearly savings growth. Ending net positions: Owning is ₹2,34,214, lower than cabs at ₹2,39,336 under these assumptions. Try these inputs
A ₹8,00,000 car costing ₹12,000 monthly to run is compared with 600 cab kilometres monthly at ₹18 per kilometre over 5 years, assuming 15% yearly depreciation, 5% annual running-cost increases and 8% yearly savings growth. Ending net positions: Owning is ₹3,54,964, lower than cabs at ₹12,88,564 under these assumptions. Try these inputs
A ₹16,00,000 car costing ₹24,000 monthly to run is compared with 600 cab kilometres monthly at ₹22 per kilometre over 15 years, assuming 15% yearly depreciation, 5% annual running-cost increases and 9% yearly savings growth. Ending net positions: Owning is ₹1,39,767, lower than cabs at ₹1,15,65,236 under these assumptions. Try these inputs
A ₹40,00,000 car costing ₹25,000 monthly to run is compared with 600 cab kilometres monthly at ₹30 per kilometre over 20 years, assuming 15% yearly depreciation, 5% annual running-cost increases and 10% yearly savings growth. Ending net positions: Owning is ₹1,55,038, lower than cabs at ₹3,68,27,657 under these assumptions. Try these inputs
Questions
At what distance does owning win?
When cab fares for your distance are well above the car's running costs. Move the distance slider to find the point where the lines cross.
What should go into the cost of owning?
Fuel, insurance, parking, servicing, tyres, cleaning and any driver's salary. Leave out the price: it is handled separately.
What about long trips and holidays?
Add an estimate of rental or train costs for those trips to the cab side, divided across the year.
Does it include a car loan?
No. If you would borrow, add the monthly interest to the cost of owning, or see the car cash or loan page.
Sources
Add it to your site
Show this calculator on your own website or blog, free. It keeps working as we update it.
HaatBeat