Money decisions

Should you rent or buy a home?

A rent payment and a mortgage instalment pay for different things. Renting buys a place to live for a period; buying combines housing with an asset and a long borrowing commitment. A fair comparison follows both households over the same number of years.

By HaatBeat AI Labs · Published

A household example to try

A fictional couple in India compares a ₹80,00,000 home with ₹25,000.00 monthly rent. A 20% down payment commits ₹16,00,000 before buying costs. Enter these values and a five-year comparison period. The renter starts with the capital that buying would use.

Add the local purchase and sale costs, then compare net assets after outstanding debt. A gross property price is not the amount a seller would keep. The figures are illustrative local budgets, not market prices or currency conversions.

Start with the same capital

Use a realistic property price, down payment, buying costs and comparable rent. The renter starts with the money that the buyer commits upfront. In this model, whichever household has spare money after its housing costs invests that surplus. The result depends on actually saving it.

Count what you would keep at the end

For the buyer, look at the estimated selling price less the remaining loan and selling costs. For the renter, look at the accumulated investments. Comparing gross property value with a savings balance would overlook the outstanding debt. The year-by-year chart helps show when the projected relationship changes.

Test the uncertain inputs

Enter your likely length of stay, then try a shorter one. Buying and selling costs can matter much more over a brief stay. Test slower property growth, faster rent increases and a lower investment return separately. The calculator uses steady rates; it cannot forecast a particular neighbourhood or market.

Consider the costs the model leaves outside

Maintenance and transaction costs have inputs, but taxes and changing insurance costs need a separate local check. A home may also tie up money needed for emergencies. Flexibility to move, control over the property and the ability to handle repairs remain part of the decision even when a projection favours one option.

Try it with your numbers

Change the inputs below to explore this guide. The starting values are examples.

How would you buy?
₹
The purchase price of the home.
%
The percentage of the home price you pay upfront (loan mode only). Cash mode uses 100%.
% a year
The annual interest rate on the home loan. 0% to 15%.
%
The annual percentage increase in the home value. Negative values mean declining value.
₹
The monthly rent you would pay if you did not buy.
% a year
The annual return on invested money (the difference between rent and EMI + maintenance). Long-term typical range is 6% to 12%.
years
1 to 40 years.
More assumptions 5
years
1 to 30 years.
%
Registration, stamp duty, inspection and legal fees as a percentage of the home price.
%
Upkeep, repairs, property tax and insurance as a percentage of current home value per year.
%
The annual percentage increase in rent.
%
Real estate agent commission, taxes and fees if sold, as a percentage of home value.
Renting ahead after 20 years
₹1,08,21,199
1.08 crore

Under these assumptions, renting and investing ends about ₹1,08,21,199 (1.08 crore) ahead of buying after 20 years. Renting stays ahead throughout.

How the net worth adds up
Buying: net worth₹2,38,12,981
Renting and investing: net worth₹3,46,34,180
Total rent paid₹79,35,829
Total loan interest₹64,96,655
Total upkeep₹28,47,786
Renting ahead by₹1,08,21,199
Then change the inputs to compare two options side by side.
Illustrative estimate. This calculator assumes fixed rates and returns, ignores tax, insurance variations, transaction timing, currency fluctuations, and the emotional value of home ownership. Treat it as one factor in your decision, not financial advice.

Net worth by year

01 crore2 crore3 crore4 crore036912151820
BuyRent and invest
YearBuy: net worthRent: net worthDifference
1₹19,89,914₹27,00,338-₹7,10,425
2₹25,92,113₹34,31,303-₹8,39,190
3₹32,34,133₹42,22,773-₹9,88,640
4₹39,18,691₹50,80,074-₹11,61,382
5₹46,48,694₹60,09,015-₹13,60,321
6₹54,27,254₹70,15,935-₹15,88,681
7₹62,57,706₹81,07,753-₹18,50,047
8₹71,43,620₹92,92,020-₹21,48,400
9₹80,88,824₹1,05,76,979-₹24,88,156
10₹90,97,415₹1,19,71,630-₹28,74,215
11₹1,01,73,788₹1,34,85,796-₹33,12,009
12₹1,13,22,651₹1,51,30,207-₹38,07,556
13₹1,25,49,054₹1,69,16,578-₹43,67,525
14₹1,38,58,408₹1,88,57,703-₹49,99,295
15₹1,52,56,521₹2,09,67,557-₹57,11,036
16₹1,67,49,617₹2,32,61,403-₹65,11,786
17₹1,83,44,378₹2,57,55,915-₹74,11,537
18₹2,00,47,970₹2,84,69,308-₹84,21,338
19₹2,18,68,086₹3,14,21,482-₹95,53,396
20₹2,38,12,981₹3,46,34,180-₹1,08,21,199

Sources and assumptions

Formulas and input conventions: HaatBeat calculator methodology. Examples are illustrative. This guide is not financial, investment, legal or tax advice.

Editorial policy · Report a correction

More from the blog

  • Investing

    How compound interest works

    Understand compounding, regular contributions and nominal versus effective rates. Test your own assumptions with the compound interest calculator.

  • Money decisions

    Mortgage overpayment vs investing

    Compare loan interest saved with an illustrative investment scenario, including liquidity, fees and risk. Try the prepay versus invest calculator.

  • Loans

    Reduce EMI or loan tenure?

    See why a lower payment and a shorter loan term have different effects after prepayment. Compare both paths with the loan prepayment calculator.

  • Money decisions

    Should you pay cash or take a loan for a car?

    Compare buying the same car with cash against financing it and investing retained savings, while keeping the monthly budget equal.

  • Investing

    How to use a SIP calculator for regular saving

    Try monthly saving, an initial deposit and annual increases. Read contributions, projected growth and the schedule using US, European and Indian examples.

  • Loans

    How to read a loan payment calculator result

    Understand monthly payments, total interest and loan balances. Compare terms with reproducible US, euro and India examples and recognise excluded fees.

  • Planning

    Future prices and purchasing power

    See why future prices rise while a fixed balance buys less. Work through local household examples and separate inflation assumptions from forecasts.